I’ve finished watching the Rings of Power with my kids. I think it is fairly safe to say that it is an absolute abomination re: Tolkien’s legacy and lore.
That said, I was able to appreciate the production and that it was a show that I felt comfortable watching with my kids given my often strict parental oversight.
Still, while the show didn’t give me Wheel of Time-levels of rage, it certainly frustrates me that low rent writers were given the chance to bastardize a body of work that no other writers should have ever had a chance to touch.
One thing that struck me with both RoP and WoT was that the writers for some reason felt the need to create a mystery where none needed to exist solely for the sake of driving interest in the story and in doing so completely went off track.
The hubris in the intern-level writing rooms is really having a massively negative impact on some of these recent adaptations and I fear for future projects that cede too much control to script writers and show runners.