The Royal Library of Alexandria (SP Book Discussion)

bmemedec

2 Likes

Oh, Declare was terrific. I totally dug The Drawing of the Dark. On Stranger Tides and The Anubis Gates were quite good. Overall, I’m still very impressed with Powers (and I think it was you and others here who brought him to my attention, and you have my gratitude). That’s largely why Last Call, which was inventive and interesting, still managed to be a disappointment.

2 Likes

Ahhh, yes, we’ve discussed it before, apologies.

No need! I’m always glad to see Tim Powers advocacy.

1 Like

I had fun with Starter Villain. Definitely lighter fare, and that’s a Good Thing sometimes. Scalzi + Wil Wheaton = Audible gold.

3 Likes

Loved Starter Villain! Highly recommend it.

2 Likes


Top 10. Alan Moore does superhero cops in a way that doesn’t lose anything from either genre, and it’s just superb. The writing is amazing, how this isn’t a Netflix series is beyond me, and Ha’s art goes from stupendously grandiose vistas to the intimately personal from page to page. This is the first book where I’ve appreciated the individual panel view option because the framing is that good. I still have my original comics of this, and I never managed a complete run. After twenty years I finally have read all of this short series.


Amusingly written, if a little too neoliberal for me, and of course it stops at Elizabeth I instead of getting into the modern lot.


Laughed my back off. Essentially, if you haven’t seen Garth Marenghi’s Darkplace then you should, and this book is a continuation of the central conceit, a horror writer incapable of anything but terrible prose, overwriting, self-inserts, and generally mistreating everyone around him. This is up there with Ayoade’s audiobooks, and only the man himself can do them justice. Wanders close to becoming turgid at times, but is relentlessly rescued by plumbing minutiae, crassly-written female characters, awful nonsensical plotting, and every other writing sin you can think of, finished off with the commentary of a talentless hack who doesn’t understand anything and has zero self-awareness. Perfect.

Babel, R.F. Kuang. I can see why it was nominated for the Hugo. Ultimately, I was a bit disappointed in how consistently angry it felt. That could have been sufficiently leavened by cool etymology and a magic system all about words, but I’m kind of feeling like I’ve had enough of books telling readers how important books and stories and words are. I get that the audience self-selects, so books can make readers feel special this way. But it feels like empty pandering, and, now that Get X is making strong inroads in the “domination of Christmas music” and “stupid media/toys from our childhood becoming culturally massive” space, I feel like I’ve just had enough of that.

I’m cool with books about why colonialism is bad and how to resist it. But this one just banged that drum a lot in proportion to the hope or insight it had to offer. And it clearly flirted with moral complexity by choosing China as the primary aim of the anti-colonial effort and briefly noting that the Chinese were also limiting the export of valuable knowledge, but it just sort of … moved on from that, and treated China purely as an uncomplicated victim of empire.

In retrospect, I felt like the mood of the Poppy War series was just a bit more mean and bleak than I was really able to enjoy, and that’s kind of how I felt here, too. I’m thinking I just don’t get on well with Kuang’s overall vibe, despite finding the worldbuilding excellent.

5 Likes

I finished the Earthsea series recently. Embarrassingly, I have always gotten Ursula Le Guin confused with Madeleine L’Engle, and what I read of L’Engle’s work seemed fine, but not entirely to my taste, so I never got into Le Guin in my youth. Earthsea struck me as insightful and gentle in a way I don’t always want, but sometimes find very appealing (and a nice contrast to Kuang).

So, I went to our bookshelf and found that my wife had an old copy of The Dispossessed. She had told me that it was just okay when she read it as an adolescent, and it’s … still just okay. Reads a bit like Bradbury’s deliberately anachronistic futures in a few places, which is entertaining, because it’s only because technology has gone in different directions than it was expected to. Culturally, that’s a bit weirder, because there’s an attempt to think through a truly egalitarian society which only mostly works (there’s one scene of sexual violence late in the book which lands very strangely now, and doesn’t make a lot of sense to me given the rest of the context of the perpetrating character). But it’s very much an exploration of the idea of anarchism more than a pure story, and it’s pretty neat that it basically does what it needs to do: imagine a radically different set of social norms to enforce anarchism, and also consider how those would gradually erode the basis for anarchism in the society and replace it with power structures which maintained the illusion of freedom and equality.

Not a great book, but effective, in its way. But then, it’s relatively easy to write a book which leaves people thinking that the ideals of anarchism are noble, but that it would be massively challenging and unstable to set up. If nobody’s taking your imagined society as an end they could reasonably hope to aspire to, it’s not going to get the sort of scrutiny it might if it seemed more imminent. So it’s possible for the imagined society to be shallowly conceived in certain ways, and readers won’t notice.

4 Likes


A novel that quickly slides from bizarre comedy into horror. A series of crimes replicate the murder of Emmet Till, except with white victims, and then things start really getting weird. A lot of deadpan humour, which I like, and although it gets a little too strange very quickly, and the early part of the book loses some effectiveness because of it, overall it’s well worth buying in to.

1 Like

IMG_1329 IMG_1328 IMG_1327

Recent reading. Zone One is a decent enough zombie novel set in the recovery after the zombie apocalypse, following a team clearing office buildings in lower Manhattan. Obviously it ends badly.

The Antony Beevor book is by now a classic, showing just how bad a general Montgomery was and how bad a plan Market Garden was. Obviously everything ended badly, especially if you happened to be a Dutch civilian in the occupied Netherlands afterwards.

Number Go Up has a few interesting strands. One is following FTX and Sam Bankman-Freed during the collapse of the business, and it’s clear that Zeke Faux didn’t know what conclusion to draw. The impression is that SBF was just entitled and careless, rather than actively criminal. A second strand is the pure weirdness of the NFT market and the subculture. The final, darkest, strand follows Tether and its links to human trafficking and organised crime, and wonders at its inexplicable robustness.

Plus a bunch of books about running as I’ve taken up dragging my increasingly creaky body around the local park and woods and need the inspiration.

3 Likes

I have run off and on throughout my life and often start again in the spring. This is the only book I’ve ever read about running, and it’s very good.

3 Likes

Love the Beevor book.

I think I actually reviewed it!

1 Like


Pulls no punches in depicting necromancy and violence in Europe during the Renaissance, as a witch attempts to avoid becoming the latest in a long line of victims of a necromancer. Excellent prose, some fine characterisation, and a well-realised historical setting.

3 Likes

And I have now read it too. So very good.

1 Like


As much as he irritates me, he knows film quite well, and it’s immediately obvious how fundamental his love of film is. Well worth a read if you like any of the films discussed, and have a less than encyclopaedic knowledge of the films of the era.

1 Like

He really irritates me as well, but I’ve been considering this since it came out. I wish the library had this so I didn’t have to buy it…

1 Like

Definitely worth a loan. See if your library will get it in, they’re usually happy to buy or inter-library loan books (speaking as a former librarian).

1 Like


I couldn’t justify buying this for a while, as my investigators are balls-deep in a very long campaign right now, and there’s no way for me to involve Japan or move things there, but in the end my resistance crumbled, I picked it up, and I’m glad I did. 400 pages of information, plus multiple packs of maps and handouts, means you are well supported if you try to run an adventure in 1920s Japan, which is a fascinating-enough setting to involve anyone who has even the slightest curiosity about it. The book has three scenarios in it, and they make a wonderful change from the usual Sengoku or modern eras that Japanese scenarios usually get. Even though I am well acquainted with Japanese history, I still discovered some new information, and the detail about locales (especially outside of Tokyo) is completely my jam. The Japanese art throughout is choice.

Of particular delight, as a former aikidoka, was to see the founder of the martial art and his far-right ties to militarists, fascists, organised crime, and secret societies, all get a mention, however minor. I’m going to crowbar all this stuff in somehow, later rather than sooner, but still.

4 Likes

I am listening to “Empire of Pain” as audiobook, absolutely brilliantly written (and read) in the German version, but I assume the English version is of the same quality… an absolute must read if you are somehow affiliated in the medical field…

I am far from through with it, but I am just blown away of how well this book is written and researched… Broadly speaking, it is addressing the corruption of politics, FDA, physician, media, through the pharma industry, from the early beginning of industrial pharmaceuticals post WW2, up until our modern days and the opioid crisis… It is written in a very captivating way, as if you were reading a crime story, only based on real people and events.

Edited for minor language corrections

2 Likes